A bill pausing state AI regulation — preempting state law while a federal framework is built
H.R.5388, the American Artificial Intelligence Leadership and Uniformity Act, provides a national framework to sustain American leadership in artificial intelligence, requires an actionable federal plan aligned to that policy, and establishes a temporary moratorium preempting certain state laws that restrict AI models and systems engaged in interstate commerce.
Bill overview (primary data)
- Bill numberH.R. 5388
- TypeHouse Bill
- Congress119th Congress
- Latest actionReferred to the Subcommittee on Oversight and Investigations.(2025-12-19)
Key points
- H.R.5388 provides a national AI framework and federal plan and establishes a temporary moratorium preempting certain state laws.
- The moratorium covers state laws restricting AI models and systems engaged in interstate commerce.
- The findings state that a patchwork of divergent state rules creates conflicting requirements and can deter investment.
- Disproportionate compliance burdens on small businesses are among the stated reasons for seeking uniformity.
- It separately defines artificial intelligence model and automated decision system, the latter turning on materially influencing or replacing human decision-making.
1Who decides, the federal government or the states
Any attempt to regulate AI in the United States runs into the question of whether Congress decides or the states do. States move faster than the federal government, and in practice state law has arrived first. What this bill does is pause that flow, establishing a temporary moratorium under which federal law preempts certain state laws restricting AI models and systems engaged in interstate commerce.
2The reasons stated in the findings
- 1Assessment of the presentThe United States leads the world in AI through a thriving innovation, investment and development environment and a flexible, sector-specific regulatory framework
- 2Where the problem liesA patchwork of divergent state AI rules creates conflicting requirements, forces firms to navigate multiple agencies and can deter investment
- 3Uneven impactSmall businesses face disproportionate compliance burdens
- 4The competitive frameGlobal competitors are racing to develop and deploy these technologies for strategic advantage
That small businesses appear third among the reasons stands out. Meeting rules that differ by state carries fixed costs, and the burden falls harder the smaller the firm. The case for uniformity is framed around fairness of entry rather than the convenience of large companies.
3How the definitions are written
Section 2 separates artificial intelligence model from automated decision system. The former is a software component producing outputs from inputs; the latter issues a simplified output such as a score, classification or recommendation to materially influence or replace human decision-making.
The latter is the one more likely to draw regulation, and the drafting reads as drawing the line by how a system cuts into human judgment rather than by the model itself.
4The word temporary
The moratorium is temporary, framed as holding while the federal framework and an actionable plan are put in place. It is described as securing time until the federal government decides rather than permanently taking authority from the states. That said, states being unable to act in the interim has substantive effect. Of the 120 bills this site holds as of 2026-09-02, 94 (78 percent) remain referred to committee.
Why it matters
For firms that have been complying state by state, whether federal preemption passes would reshape compliance design from the ground up. Drawing the line at automated decision systems that cut into human judgment, rather than at models themselves, also matters for reading regulatory reach.
FAQ
What is preemption?
Why do small businesses feature in the reasoning?
Sources (primary)
Source: Congress.gov (Library of Congress; U.S. legislative materials, public domain). Links go to the official site.
- Congress.gov (bill page, original)
- H.R. 5388(119th Congress)